Wednesday, 22 July 2026

 

 

LATEST NEWS Bhagwan Jagannath’s Rath Yatra a Living Symbol of Indian Culture, Social Harmony and Service- Nayab Singh Saini Congress stages protest at Congress Bhawan against paper leaks, police brutality on students Congress Using NEET to Revive Failing Politics, Silent on Punjab Exam Scams Every News Report Becomes a Document of Its Time- Nayab Singh Saini Haryana CM Nayab Singh Saini Unveils Major MSME, Startup and Industrial Reforms Under Vision @2047 Explore modern and advanced technology for the Printing and Stationery Department: Prof Ashim Kumar Ghosh Haryana Governor inaugurates renovation work of Gaushala Krishan Lal Panwar chairs District Public Grievances Committee meeting, orders to Register FIR Against Ansal API Without Delay Complete Remaining Work of Ganaur India International Horticulture Market Project at the Earliest- Shyam Singh Rana Haryana Govt Approves ₹35 Lakh Advanced Bionic Limbs for Panipat Child Who Lost Limbs in Electrocution Kavinder Gupta calls for integrating Indian knowledge systems with modern education 500+ athletes supported, four Commonwealth Games qualifiers: Axis Bank and IIS strengthen India’s judo talent pipeline Punjab Becomes 1st State in India to Introduce Artificial Intelligence as Mainstream Subject From Class I to XII says Harjot Bains Godrej Capital enters Gold Loans through the acquisition of Kanakadurga Finance Limited’s Gold Loan business Fly to the 'Land of Smiles' with AirAsia YES BANK Partners with Indian Olympic Association as Official Retail Banking Partner for Team India 2026 BJP Govt. could have made Himachal a debt-free state says Sukhvinder Singh Sukhu AAP government has marginalised the bureaucracy and is blatantly criminalising politics says Sunil Jakhar Amarinder Singh Raja Warring demands Mann’s, Bains’ resignation over paper leaks in Punjab Shweta Tripathi Reflects on Mirzapur's Iconic Journey as Franchise Heads to the Big Screen Ravinder Singh Kheda Raises Issue of Non-Operational Sewerage Line on Nijjar Road

 

Prashant Bhushan pays Re 1 fine, files review plea against conviction

Web Admin

Web Admin

5 Dariya News

New Delhi , 14 Sep 2020

Last updated on: Sep 14, 2020, 00:00 IST

Advocate Prashant Bhushan on Monday filed a review petition in the Supreme Court, challenging its verdict convicting him for criminal contempt of court by making derogatory statements against the judiciary through tweets.On September 12, Bhushan had moved a plea filed in the apex court seeking a right of appeal against his conviction, to be heard by a larger and a different bench. The top court had imposed a token penalty of Re 1 on Bhushan, which he deposited in the court on Monday.Addressing the media, Bhushan said that paying the fine does not mean he had accepted the verdict and he would file a review plea to contest his conviction.Bhushan has, in his plea, argued that tweet number 2 tends to convey an impression that "the judges who have presided in the Supreme Court in the period of last six years have a particular role in the destruction of Indian democracy and the last four CJIs had a more particular role in it.""This might well be the impression that the tweet in question seeks to convey, but the Court doesn't, in fact, show, or even attempt to show, how the holding of this opinion constitutes contempt of court. This is an error apparent on the face of the judgment," said Bhushan in the 444-page review petition.On August 31, a bench headed by Justice Arun Mishra, who retired on September 2, had said: "We, therefore, sentence the contemnor (Bhushan) with a fine of Re 1 to be deposited with the Registry of this Court by September 15, failing which he shall undergo a simple imprisonment for a period of three months and further be debarred from practising in this Court for a period of three years."Bhushan insisted the court erroneously held him guilty of contempt, as the fair criticism of a judge and the judiciary is protected by Article 19 (1)(a) of the Constitution.He argued that contempt proceedings should not have been heard by a bench comprising Justice Mishra. "That on several occasions, Justice Arun Mishra has orally accused the review petitioner of committing contempt of court when he had merely mentioned that it may be inappropriate for a particular judge to hear a particular case in circumstances where conflict of interest was involved," said the review plea.Bhushan urged the apex court to rehear the verdict which held him guilty of contempt and also grant an oral hearing in the open court, as the facts and circumstances of the case so necessitated."The impugned judgment has erred in concluding that the tweets are based on 'distorted facts', because, by its own admission, it has pointedly refused to go into the legitimacy and the veracity of the statements made in Tweet No. 2. It is submitted that this inconsistency is writ large on the face of the record," Bhushan contended in the plea.The top court considered that Bhushan's second tweet on judiciary undermines the dignity and authority of the institution of the Supreme Court and the Chief Justice of India and directly affronts the majesty of law and is therefore contumacious.Bhushan, however, argued that, "in fact, a facet of any test has to determine what constitutes criminal contempt, and in holding Tweet No. 2 as contumacious because it has undermined the dignity of the court or because it has affronted the majesty of law, the impugned judgment has clearly erred."

 

Tags: Prashant Bhushan

 

 

related news

 

 

 

5 Dariya News RNI Code: PUNMUL/2011/49000
© 2011-2026 | 5 Dariya News | All Rights Reserved
Powered by: CDS PVT LTD