Wednesday, 22 May 2024

 

 

LATEST NEWS Heat Wave Management- Mohali Admin Issues Advisory to beat heat wave Drugs, Cash and other valuables worth Rs 10 Crore seized since enforcement of code in the district, says DEO Aashika Jain CGC Landran’s IQAC organises short term course on Outcome-based Education Program for Accreditation BJP asked for votes in favor of BJP candidate in village Sambhalki Urvashi Rautela Net Worth 2024 | Know The Urvashi Rautela’s Bio, Career, and Lifestyle A Comprehensive Guide How To Watch Turkish Dramas in Hindi Dubbed Online | 5 Dariya News 8 Best Brain Games That Will Boost Your Brain Power Top 10 Turkish Movie on Netflix List 2024 | 5 Dariya News DC Samba Abhishek Sharma chairs border security assessment meeting DC Jammu Sachin Kumar Vaishya discusses action plan for rehabilitation of street children DC Srinagar Dr. Bilal Mohi-Ud-Din Bhat visits Yatra Transit Camp Pantha Chowk, oversees preparations for annual Shri Amarnath Ji Yatra-2024 RO Srinagar PC reviews preparedness regarding arrangements for Counting of Votes Lt Governor Manoj Sinha interacts with Yuva Sangam’s youth delegation from Maharashtra under Ek Bharat Shreshtha Bharat initiative DC Jammu Sachin Kumar Vaishya sets timelines for execution of JJM works Div Com Jammu Ramesh Kumar reviews progress of work on DAK expressway in Reasi District DC Samba Abhishek Sharma chairs district-level NCORD committee meeting SVEEP Team organises mega voters’ awareness rally at Rajouri Secretary Health Dr. Syed Abid Rasheed Shah conducts administrative inspection of GDC Srinagar Randomization for shop pitching during SANJY-2024 held at Ganderbal Final Orientation/ Training programme organised for Presiding Officers, Polling Staff at Shopian DC Ganderbal Shyambir emphasizes foolproof mechanism for annual Kheer Bhawani mela

 

Live-telecast attaches stricter responsibility on judges, adverse remarks may harm reputation : SC

Supreme Court, The Supreme Court Of India, New Delhi
Listen to this article

Web Admin

Web Admin

5 Dariya News

New Delhi , 22 Mar 2023

The Supreme Court has said that though virtual hearings and live-telecast of court proceedings introduces transparency in the judicial system, it also attaches with it a stricter standard of responsibility on judges while conducting such court proceedings.

It stressed that constitutional courts should exercise caution in making adverse remarks against the parties as those may cause great harm to their reputation. 

A bench comprising justices Krishna Murari and Ahsanuddin Amanullah said,; "It is essential for the courts to be extremely cautious while passing adverse remarks against the parties involved, and must do so with proper justification, in the right forum, and only if it is necessary to meet the ends of justice".

Justice Murari, who authored the judgment on behalf of the bench, said remarks passed in court, due to the live broadcasting of court proceedings, now have ramifications that are far reaching, and as can be seen in the present case, can cause great injury to the reputation of the parties involved.

The top court made these observations while expunging adverse remarks made by the Karnataka High Court against senior IPS officer Seemant Kumar Singh, the then Additional Director General of Police, Anti Corruption Bureau and IAS officer J Manjunath, then district collector of Bengaluru in a bail plea by an accused in a corruption case. 

The bench said that the remarks made by the high court "seem to be unreasonable and without justification". The top court said the legal system in general, and the judicial system in particular, has ushered into a new age of accessibility and transparency due to the adoption of virtual hearings and live telecasting of open court proceedings. 

These changes in the judiciary have ensured that the courts as redressal mechanisms have become more accessible to the common man than ever before, it added. Justice Murari said: "This never-before-seen transparency in the judicial system, while it brings with it great benefits, it also attaches with it a stricter standard of responsibility on judges while conducting such court proceedings".

The bench quashed an interim order passed by the high court on July 7, last year after hearing senior advocates Ranjit Kumar and Amit Kumar and advocate Sanjay M Nuli and Additional Solicitor General K M Nataraj on appeals filed by the officers as well as the Karnataka government.

The bench said: "We are of the opinion that the actions of the high court during the bail proceedings of a third party are manifestly arbitrary and unjust, and the high court must have confined itself to the issues relevant to it for the purposes of deciding the bail".

The bench stressed that when the evidence is not fully analysed, and a presumption of innocence is still operational in favour of the accused, the courts must then be extremely cautious in passing adverse remarks against the accused.

For Singh, the bench said he is merely a government employee of the department that is conducting the investigation and has no personal involvement with the case. "No evidence against him has been analysed by the court and no opportunity has been given to him to explain himself, however, scathing and egregious remarks have still been passed against him. 

In such a scenario, we find the remarks passed by the high court to be unfair and not in the interest of justice," said the bench. For Manjunath, the court said even though he is an accused in the alleged crime, however, what must not be forgotten is the fact that he does not have any lis in the bail proceedings of an accused police officer in a corruption case.

The top court noted that bail proceedings, unlike a full criminal trial, are burdened with the task of only forming a prima facie view on the merits of the case. In such a circumstance when the evidence is not fully analyzed, and a presumption of innocence is still operational in favour of the accused, the courts must then be extremely cautious in passing adverse remarks against the accused, it added.

 

Tags: Supreme Court , The Supreme Court Of India , New Delhi

 

 

related news

 

 

 

Photo Gallery

 

 

Video Gallery

 

 

5 Dariya News RNI Code: PUNMUL/2011/49000
© 2011-2024 | 5 Dariya News | All Rights Reserved
Powered by: CDS PVT LTD