Friday, 22 September 2023



LATEST NEWS Director Agriculture Chowdhury Mohammad Iqbal visits Saffron Fields of Pampore RDD, SWD departments organize Awareness programmes on drug abuse Several delegations of Lar call on DC Ganderbal Shyambir DC Kulgam Dr. Bilal Mohi-Ud-Din Bhat reviews modalities for proper implementation of ABDP in Manzgam block Technical Education department introduces nine new courses: Harjot Singh Bains DC Ganderbal Shyambir inaugurates Block Conference Hall at Block Office Kangan Divisional Commissioner Vijay Kumar Bidhuri reviews functioning of KPDCL, KPTCL, PHE, R&B Departments District Level NCORD Committee reviews anti-drug measures in Kathua District CM Bhagwant Mann Hands Over Cheques Worth Rs One Crore Each As Financial Assistance To Distressed Families Of Two Brave Hearts Martyred At Anantnag DC Rajouri Vikas Kundal reviews pace of progress on JJM Water Supply Schemes in Rajouri Facilitation Centre cum Sale Counter for value added products opened at Govt Fruit Plant Nursery Siot Drugs Awareness Program organised in District Samba DC Udhampur Saloni Rai inaugurates Dogra Haat- Rural market hub in Kaghote Ramnagar Ghost: Diljit Dosanjh Reveals The Release Date Of His Upcoming Album DC Kathua Rakesh Minhas reviews performance of line departments; development scenario in Kathua district Former Minister Sukhnandan Choudhary Public delegations call on Lt Governor Manoj Sinha Asian Games: Hockey Captain Harmanpreet Singh Named India's Flag-Bearer of the Indian Contingent Punjab Health Department Busts Three Illegal Sex Determination Rackets Across State Shubh Replies Back To His India Tour Cancellation, Says, “I’m Extremely Disheartened” Salman Khan Ignites Gippy Grewal‘s starrer 'Maujaan Hi Maujaan' Trailer Launch With His Dabangg Style International Sikh Martial Arts Council resolves for advancement of Gatka worldwide


Governor can't call for floor test based on difference of opinion of MLAs in party : SC

Supreme Court, The Supreme Court Of India, New Delhi
Listen to this article

Web Admin

Web Admin

5 Dariya News

New Delhi , 15 Mar 2023

The Supreme Court on Wednesday observed that the Governor cannot lend his office to effectuate a particular result as it questioned if could the difference of opinion among MLAs within a party could become a sufficient ground for the Governor to call for the floor test?

B.S. Koshyari, who was then the Governor of Maharashtra, had asked the then Chief Minister Uddhav Thackeray to face a floor test to prove his majority. Thackeray, sensing imminent defeat, resigned and this resulted in the appointment of Shinde as the new Chief Minister.

A five-judge bench headed by Chief Justice D.Y. Chandrachud asked Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, representing the Maharashtra Governor, how a difference of opinion among MLAs within a party could become a sufficient ground for the Governor to call for the floor test?

The top court made these observations after Mehta narrated the sequence of events and said there were various materials before the Governor, which prompted him to order a trust vote.

The bench further added that the Governor cannot lend his office to effectuate a particular result and emphasised that calling for a trust vote will lead to toppling of the elected government.

Mehta said the material included: a letter signed by 34 Shiv Sena MLAs, a letter from independent lawmakers withdrawing support to the Uddhav Thackeray government, and another letter from the Leader of the Opposition.

The bench also comprising Justices M.R. Shah, Krishna Murari, Hima Kohli and P.S. Narasimha - said the opposition leader's letter did not matter and also the letter from MLAs citing threat to their security was also not relevant in this case.

The bench questioned Mehta if could widespread discontent among the party cadres and legislators' sufficient ground to call for a trust vote? The bench orally observed: "People will start ditching the ruling party and Governors being willing allies would end up toppling the ruling party. 

This will be a sad spectacle for democracy." The bench said Congress and Nationalist Congress Party (NCP) remained a solid bloc and it was only Shiv Sena, where there was dissension and questioned Mehta, can this dissension be sufficient to ask the Chief Minister to face the floor test. 

"This is our concern and it is very dangerous for democracy," it added. The Chief Justice said suppose a group of MLAs feels their leader has deviated from the party discipline, then they can always ask for a change of leadership at a forum within the party, but where is the room for the Governor to call for a floor test based on the dissension.

Senior advocate Kapil Sibal, representing the Thackeray faction, in his rejoinder submission said, "We are back to a position of 'aaya Ram-gaya Ram..." He added that now your political affiliation does not matter, what matters is numbers. 

The hearing in the matter will continue on Thursday. The top court is hearing petitions in connection with Maharashtra political crisis triggered due to rebellion in Shiv Sena.


Tags: Supreme Court , The Supreme Court Of India , New Delhi



related news




Photo Gallery



Video Gallery



5 Dariya News RNI Code: PUNMUL/2011/49000
© 2011-2023 | 5 Dariya News | All Rights Reserved
Powered by: CDS PVT LTD