Thursday, 28 October 2021



LATEST NEWS Meenakshi Lekhi inaugurates first ever Lit Festival at Gulmarg as part of iconic week celebrations Lt Governor attends commemoration of the 75th year of Air Induction of Indian Army to evict Pakistan forces from Kashmir Lt Governor inaugurates Brig. S S Kahlon Artificial Sports Climbing Wall at Jawahar Institute of Mountaineering and Winter Sports Nyra Banerjee on her role in 'Barun Rai and the House on the Cliff' IANS Review: 'Hypnotic': Fails to be compelling as a psycho-thriller 'Bigg Boss 15': Rajiv Adatia's secret about 'relationship' with Ieshaan Sehgaal Administrative Council extends relief under SRO 43 to the next of kin of violence victims Dr. Arun Kumar Mehta reviews implementation of Business Reform Action Plan /Ease of Doing Business reforms in J&K Advisor Farooq Ahmad Khan reviews crop losses due to recent rains, hailstorm in Jammu division Vigilance awareness week: Integrity Pledge held across Kashmir Officer Trainees of Indian Information Service call on JDIPR, Jammu Mayor JMC flags off walkthone to promote Heritage tourism Corridor of Jammu City J&K IMPARD observes Vigilance Awareness Week at Jammu, Srinagar Congress government betrayed unemployed of Punjab at every step : Harpal Singh Cheema SAD To Move Assembly Resolution To Direct State For A Cabinet Decision To Block Central Moves On Farm Laws And BSF Punjab Cabinet Decides To Summon Special Assembly Session On November 8 CM lays foundation stone of Sports Stadium in memory of farmers who lost their lives during farm laws agitation Charanjit Singh Channi Announces To Scrap 40,000 Cases Of Vat Against Industrialists And Traders Will Launch New Party Once EC Clears Name & Symbol : Captain Amarinder Singh Captain Amarinder Singh To Lead Delegation Of Non-Political Agriculture Experts To Meet Shah On Farmers’ Stir Captain Amarinder Singh Slams Punjab Govt For Being In Denial Mode Over Growing Security Threat


Supreme Court strikes down Maratha reservation law, rules out review of 50% cap on quota

Supreme Court

Web Admin

Web Admin

5 Dariya News

New Delhi , 05 May 2021

In a major decision, the Supreme Court on Wednesday termed the 2018 Maharashtra law, providing reservations to Marathas in jobs and education, as unconstitutional, and struck it down for violating the 50 per cent cap on quota and the fundamental right to equality.A five-judge Constitution bench, by a unanimous view, also ruled out any need to reconsider the 1992 nine-judge bench judgement in Indra Sawhney (Mandal Commission) case, which fixed 50 per cent ceiling on reservation. "We have found that no extraordinary circumstances were made out in granting separate reservation of Maratha community by exceeding the 50 per cent ceiling limit of reservation," the top court noted.The 569-page verdict may likely have far-reaching consequences on pending challenges to the validity of the Centre's 10 percent Economic Weaker Section quota, and Tamil Nadu's law for up to 69 percent reservation for the OBC. Against the backdrop of this verdict, the governments would have to prove exceptional circumstances to support their move.The top court said the 2018 Maharashtra Act violates the principle of equality as enshrined in Article 16. The exceeding of ceiling limit without there being any extra-ordinary circumstances clearly violates Article 14 and 16 of the Constitution which makes the enactment ultra vires, it added.Several states had demanded review for the nine-judge bench decision in view of subsequent developments and change in social dynamics.

But the court stayed unmoved.Justice Ashok Bhushan writing on behalf of himself, and Justice S. Abdul Nazeer said: "There can be no quarrel that society changes, law changes, and people change but that does not mean that something which is good and proven to be beneficial in maintaining equality in the society should also be changed in the name of change alone."The Constitution bench, presided over by Justice Bhushan, observed that the pre-condition for breaching 50 per cent limit on quota under Article 16(4) like extra-ordinary and exceptional circumstances was not fulfilled in granting 12 percent and 13 percent reservation to Marathas in jobs and education, respectively."The representation of Marathas in public services in Grade A, B, C and D comes to 33.23 per cent, 29.03 per cent, 37.06 per cent and 36.53 per cent, computed from out of the open category filled posts, is adequate and satisfactory representation of Maratha community," it noted."One community bagging such number of posts in public services is a matter of pride for the community and its representation in no manner can be said to not adequate in public services," the top court said, also pointing out that Gaikwad Commission's data showed that Marathas are not a socially and educationally backward class.The other judges on the bench -- Justices L. Nageswara Rao, Hemant Gupta and S. Ravindra Bhat agreed that Maratha quota was unconstitutional, and no review of 50 per cent cap is required.The five-judge Constitution bench upheld validity of the 102nd Amendment which granted constitutional status to the National Commission for Backward Classes.However, Justices Bhushan and Nazeer's point of view of was not agreed by other three judges who held the state was empowered to identify the backward class for granting quota.Justice Rao said there is no obscurity in Article 342 A (1), instead it very clear that there should be one list of socially and educationally backward classes which may be issued by the President.


Tags: Supreme Court



related news




Photo Gallery



Video Gallery



5 Dariya News RNI Code: PUNMUL/2011/49000
© 2011-2021 | 5 Dariya News | All Rights Reserved
Powered by: CDS PVT LTD